One Seller Credit, Three Outcomes: Mitch Milat on Price Cuts, Discount Points, and Buydowns
Why This Choice Matters Right Now
Mitch Milat points out that the same seller credit can lead to three very different outcomes. With more sellers offering credits in today’s market, buyers have more chances to negotiate, and how you use that credit can shape your costs for years. The best choice is not the same for every buyer, so it helps to understand each option before you write an offer.
Option One: A Price Cut
Using the credit to lower the purchase price reduces your loan amount a little, and that reduction lasts for the life of the loan. A smaller loan can mean a slightly lower payment every month, and it may also reduce the interest you pay over time. The benefit is steady and simple, though it is typically more modest than the other options in the early years. Seller credit limits and how credits can be applied vary by loan program, so confirm what is allowed for your loan.
Option Two: Discount Points
Discount points lower your interest rate for as long as you keep the loan. They only pay off if you stay in the loan past the break even point, which is often around four years. If you plan to stay in the home and keep the mortgage for a long time, points may make sense. If you might sell or refinance sooner, you may not recoup the cost. The break even timeline depends on the rate reduction and the price of the points, so it should be calculated for your specific quote.
Option Three: A Temporary Buydown
A temporary buydown makes your payment lowest in the first year or two, then it steps up to the full payment. This can help buyers who want breathing room early on, such as while they settle into a new home or expect their income to grow. The tradeoff is that the lower payment is not permanent, so you should be comfortable with the full payment when the buydown period ends. Buydown structures and eligibility vary by lender and program.
None of These Is Automatically Best
Mitch emphasizes that the right answer depends on how long you plan to stay and what you need your payment to be right now. A buyer planning to stay for many years may lean toward points, while a buyer focused on early cash flow may prefer a temporary buydown, and another may value the simplicity of a lower price. Your timeline, budget, and goals should drive the decision.
See the Real Difference Before You Offer
Before you make an offer, Mitch Milat can price all three options on the same house so you can see the real difference side by side. Comparing the numbers before you negotiate helps you ask for the credit in the way that serves you best. Reach out to Mitch to run the comparison.
Sources
ConsumerFinancialProtectionBureau.gov
FreddieMac.com
Fanniemae.com
HUD.gov
NAR.realtor


